May Drama Unfolds: The Market Climbs A Wall Of Confusion
Published June 6, 2025
May turned out to be one of those months that reminded investors why the market hates uncertainty — and then proceeds to rally anyway. The S&P 500 surged 6.2 percent, the Nasdaq climbed 9.6 percent, and even the Dow managed a respectable 3.9 percent gain. Between April 8 and May 5, the size of the gain (17 percent) in the S&P 500 has occurred in such a short period only six times in the past 75 years, according to Birinyi Associates. The entire month was the best May performance for equities since 1990.
The month’s defining moment came on May 29, when a federal trade court struck down President Trump’s sweeping tariffs. Markets rallied. Then, within hours, an appeals court put the ruling on hold. The tariffs were back. So was the confusion. Companies that had spent months adjusting to the new trade rules were back to square one.
This kind of policy reversal would have been extraordinary a generation ago. Now it is becoming routine. Companies are spending more time with trade lawyers than with their customers. The regulatory burden has become so complex that businesses are shifting resources away from innovation and growth just to navigate the compliance maze.
Yet somehow, consumers kept spending. Discretionary purchases held steady in May, suggesting that Americans are either adapting to the policy chaos or accelerating their purchases ahead of tariffs. Manufacturing orders showed artificial strength as companies built inventories, not because demand was growing, but because they feared higher import costs down the road. Employment numbers remained strong, although data emerging in early June indicates there is some softening.
At the end of the month, Jamie Dimon […]