Bill Rutherford Quoted In The Wall Street Journal
Health-Stock Refuge No Refuge at All
by Vanessa Fuhrmans
In past economic downturns, investors looking for cover from falling share prices could always run to health-care stocks. This year, though, that classic safe haven appears worse than the storm.
Recession or not, people get sick and use prescription drugs, medical devices and plenty of other medical services. That’s the driving logic behind the health-care industry’s usual resistance to the economy’s twists and turns.
But so far in 2008, health-care stocks have taken an even bigger beating than most. The Dow Jones Wilshire U.S. Healthcare Index is down 11% since year end. By contrast, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is down 5.9%, after losing 3.9% last week, and the Nasdaq Composite Index is down 7.8%, after tumbling 3.3% last week.
Some of the biggest managed-care and pharmaceutical companies have led the plunge. Humana, one of last year’s top performing health insurers, is down 35% this year, while WellPoint and Health Net have dropped 39% and 36%, respectively. Among drug makers, Merck has fallen 33%, while generics maker Barr Pharmaceuticals is down 19%. […]